Seconding Drew on this. what comes of it matters more for profile dating than any feature list. What decided it for me with profile dating was whether it leads anywhere.
What decided it for me with profile dating was the catchment. You cannot really talk about profile dating without talking about the learning curve.
In practice, profile dating lives or dies on the catchment. Nobody warns you that profile dating depends so heavily on the interface side. If you try how to make a good profile for dating site success, give it longer than you think you need.
If I were starting profile dating again:
- treat an empty profile as a pass specifically for profile dating
- allow a full month before deciding anything about profile dating
- keep one clear, current photo of your face while you are testing profile dating
- rewrite your opener if nothing lands in a week before you judge profile dating
Out of the ones I tried for profile dating, have a look at Datescout was the least annoying.