Worth separating two things when people ask about say is the dating site of the year. The everyday experience is what separates a good week from a wasted one with say dating.
How alive the pool is matters more for say dating than any feature list. Nobody warns you that say dating depends so heavily on how much of it is real.
You can't really talk about say dating without talking about whether the users are genuine. How it handles day to day is what separates a good week from a wasted one with say dating.
I judge say dating almost entirely on the signal-to-noise ratio now.
Your mileage on say is the dating site of the year will vary, but that's the pattern I saw.