Going long here because the quick answer really doesn't cover it.
Outside major cities the matching pool is smaller, which makes certain features feel broken even when they're working as intended.
Things that have genuinely helped me work through issues like this:
- Free tier limitations often look like bugs — check what your tier actually includes
- Profile visibility settings are separate from match settings on most apps
- If you're seeing no one, try temporarily expanding your distance or age filters
- Log out and back in before assuming a feature is broken
Currently using Datescout as my main go-to and it's been reliable. No major surprises, decent activity, and the settings actually do what they say.
Hope that gives you something concrete to work with.