If you're asking about catholic dating for free community on Reddit, you're already ahead of where I was. My experience with catholic dating shifted completely once I paid attention to how many accounts are active. My experience with catholic dating shifted completely once I paid attention to the catchment.
You cannot really talk about catholic dating without talking about how real the profiles are. Most of the frustration with catholic dating traces back to the geography of it. I judge catholic dating almost entirely on whether there is anyone nearby now.
If you try catholic dating for free community on Reddit, give it longer than you think you need.
I still keep an account on what Datenest does purely for catholic dating.