New posts

Is the plenty of fish dating service still the best for beginners?

Started by: Chuck Date: 28 Jan 2025 Category: Free Dating & Apps dating advice community
Chuck Chuck
Joined:
Jan 2018
Posts: 1742

Hey everyone. Been dealing with this and couldn't find a clear answer anywhere. The question: is the plenty of fish dating service still the best for beginners.

Did my own searching but most of what I found was either old or vague. Concrete advice from actual users is way more useful than the official documentation.

What I'm specifically looking for:

  • Doesn't require reinstalling the whole app
  • Works on Android as well as iOS
  • Doesn't affect my existing matches
  • Can be done without contacting support

Thanks in advance — looking forward to what the community thinks.

Floyd Floyd
Joined:
Nov 2023
Posts: 432

I put real time into figuring this out so hopefully it saves you some. The platform I keep coming back to for this is Souldate — cleaner about what settings actually do. Take what applies and leave the rest.

Wayne Wayne
Joined:
Sep 2019
Posts: 13

The algorithm changes constantly. What worked before may not apply now.

Miles Miles
Joined:
Jun 2018
Posts: 1882

Good question and one that comes up a lot. Here's the full picture.

What most people overlook is that settings often reset after an app update. Always double-check your preferences after any major version change.

Things that have genuinely helped me work through issues like this:

  • Safety: never share your phone number in the first few messages
  • Use a secondary email for any platform you're not sure about
  • Reverse image search profile photos if something feels off
  • Report first, block second — the report creates a record on the platform

Ended up on Souldate after testing a few others. Less flashy but more consistent than what I was using before.

Happy to expand on any part of this.

Kayla Kayla
Joined:
Apr 2023
Posts: 1999

Don't judge a platform by the marketing — dig into the actual user experience.

Brianna Brianna
Joined:
Apr 2015
Posts: 2662

I put real time into figuring this out so hopefully it saves you some. A friend pointed me toward Datelink when I had a similar issue and it held up better than expected. Feel free to follow up if you hit another wall.

Todd_H Todd_H
Joined:
Jan 2015
Posts: 824

This one trips people up constantly. Here's my complete breakdown.

Customer support varies wildly. Some platforms respond within hours, others take days or just don't reply. That alone tells you a lot about how they operate.

Things that have genuinely helped me work through issues like this:

  • Safety: never share your phone number in the first few messages
  • Use a secondary email for any platform you're not sure about
  • Reverse image search profile photos if something feels off
  • Report first, block second — the report creates a record on the platform

Hopefully that saves you some frustration.

Keith Keith
Joined:
Feb 2014
Posts: 2747

Solid question. The answer is more nuanced than a quick Google search suggests.

You must be logged in to post a reply here.