I had the same question about dirty gay roulette heavily moderated about a year ago. If the fake-account issue is not sorted, dirty gay will not go anywhere.
What decided it for me with dirty gay was whether people actually reply.
The honest tradeoff with dirty gay is the privacy side against convenience.
The honest tradeoff with dirty gay is the trust question against convenience. What decided it for me with dirty gay was how many accounts are active.
Take that as one data point on dirty gay roulette heavily moderated, not gospel.
Three things that changed dirty gay for me:
- treat an empty profile as a pass on the dirty gay side
- allow three weeks before deciding anything about dirty gay
- leave a solid month before deciding anything about dirty gay
That is the version of dirty gay that held up for me.