Seconding Russell on this. in practice, asia date lives or dies on the profile quality. My experience with asia date shifted completely once I paid attention to how alive the pool is.
Most of the frustration with asia date traces back to how many accounts are active.
What decided it for me with asia date was whether there's anyone nearby.
Two people can have opposite results with asia date purely because of how thin it gets outside cities.
I judge asia date almost entirely on the fake-account issue now.
If you want a comparison point on asia date, Datescout recently.